Not trying to troll you here, but I don't see where the ball itself crosses the plane. I see it in his right arm, but I don't see it on that yellow line or beyond it. I suppose if we made his hand invisible I might; is that what the argument is? Look at the Atlanta defenders hand. It is on the tip of the ball (because he was about a second away from stripping it). That's across the plane. It's a bit of a blurred image because what you are thinking is the ball has a black line across it and is actually the right arm of the defender that is below Graham. While I see your point, from that view it isn't certain that the ball crosses the goal line. I cannot clearly see the ball cross, even if I think it does. Since the play was called a fumble on the field, the call stands- which means there isn't enough to overturn. I could care less who wins between Saints and Falcons, but I think, while the refs may have missed the call on the field, once it was called a fumble, the replay got it right in the way the rule is stated.