Ryne Sandberg minor league winning percentage: .516 Mike Quade minor league winning percentage: .509 Ryno's been better in the minors than Quade, but it's not a particularly significant difference. And Quade had at least one winning season at every level he managed at as well. Both managers have overall losing records at the A-ball level as well. Is a .007 better winning percentage in the minors the difference between a poor MLB manager and a good MLB manager? then what are you looking for, he has done everything asked of him and probably has learned a lot. Girardi's knowledge came from the fact he had to manage from the field as a catcher, yet like Dusty at SF, he was surrounded by talent at FL and NY. So, we really don't know if he is and incredibly, talented coach or just lucky to end up in good positions Who said anything about Girardi? what I was trying to point out is that many point to very successful manager that became such because of the owners willingness to surround them with incredibly talented players, and then continue to pay those players very well to hang around for a long time, thus making a manager look even better. We can't judge Sandberg as a manager based solely on the minors, or solely on his major league career, but together we get a little indication of his potential and willingness to learn, listen and monitor and adjust to the different levels he has been called to manage. The only way we can truly know if anybody can handle the majors is to make them a manager, like being President, previous experiences can give indications but you never no what they will do until they are in that position. I personally believe he has paid enough dues to warrant a shot.