How sick would an outfield of Matsui/Giles/Sheff be? And add it to an infield with ARod and Jeter? That's one serious offense. I thought they wanted a defensive CF?? Why do they need more offense than they already have? I guess I don't understand why you put a 35-year-old in CF when it's probably not his natural position. While Giles certainly wouldn't be a defensive wizard in CF, he has played many games there over his career. (Including 17 this past season.) He'd certainly man the position adequately, and if your CF is capable of putting up a .900-1.000 OPS, I'm sure you can make due with "adequate" defense. It'd be like us putting Burnitz in CF all of last year. Of course Giles is going to outproduce Burnitz by far. I'm just so sick and tired of the Yankees and them gobbling up every FA.