WHIP is fatally flawed, because it excludes: 1) HBP-Which is the responsibility of the pitcher. 2) No distinction between a walk and a HR. Two pitchers could have similar 1.0 WHIP. One gives up a single per inning with no runs scoring for 7 innings, while another has a HBP and a HR per inning. Both would have the same WHIP-but one has a shutout, while the other has given up 14 runs. By the way, in oft-injured Kerry Wood's best year(2003) he had 21 HBP. I checked on the correlation between 'great pitchers' with 'Wins' and 'WHIP'. My source is Baseball-Reference.Com. The 10 All-Time WHIP leaders are: Addie Jones, Ed Walsh, Pedro Martinez, John Ward, Christy Mathewson, Walter Johnson, Moredcai Brown, Charlie Sweeney, Reb Russell and Joe Wood. The 10 All-Time WIN leaders(with their WHIP #) are: Cy Young(35), Walter Johnson(6), Pete Alexander(31), Christy Mathewson(52), Pud Galvin(NA), Warren Spahn(NA), Kid Nichols(NA), Tim Keefe(NA), Roger Clemens(85) and Steve Carlton(NA). In fact, of the Top 100 winningest pitchers all-time(about 200+ victories), less than 15 are ranked in the Top 100 WHIP category. That means pitchers with higher WHIP(#-101+ all time) include: Warren Spahn(363 wins), Steve Carlton(329 wins), Nolan Ryan(324 wins), Phil Niekro(318 wins), Lefty Grove(300 wins), Early Wynn(330 wins), Tommy John, Bert Blyleven, Fergie Jenkins, Jim Kaat, Tom Glavine, Bob Feller, Bob Gibson. We needn't worry about Kerry Wood ever reaching 250 wins or HOF status.