So you expect a guy with a mediocre career minor league OBP to improve upon that OBP in his rookie season? Yes, Edmonds is going to keep declining. Do you not understand the idea of aging ballplayers? Do you think all these injuries have been faked? do you understand that aging ballplayers are capable of good seasons? do you understand the concept of the 1 year deal? goodness gracious, goony, i'm not talking about signing this guy long term. relax. Do you understand what a complete wreck Edmonds is right now? He's a shell of his former self. so is derrek lee. so is anyone who's been hurt without a history of a previous major injury. if he's been playing hurt he's capable of playing hurt a lot better than juan pierre is capable of playing injury-free. like i said, let's not sign him long term, but the production level he's at right now, as a wreck, is still better than the alternatives. wow, you'd think i was talking about re-signing willie wilson or something. There's a difference between Derrek Lee breaking a bone, and Jim Edmonds getting concussions and needing cortisone shots for various other ailments. I don't see how you can assume he'll return to his production level, because down the stretch he certainly wasn't at it, when he actually did play. concussions aren't injuries you get because you're injury prone. generally, they are injuries you get from running into something or getting hit by someone. as for the cortisone shots, i'm sure there are a lot of players that get them, especially older players. again, i don't see how anyone can point to edmonds history and say: "he's going to be worth less than juan pierre in 2007". that doesn't make sense at all.