keep telling yourself that. i don't think they are. they're good, no doubt, but i think the cubs stack up favorably position-for-position. it's close. 1B: ad cubs 2B: ad brewers 3B: ad cubs SS: ad brewers C: ad push CF: ad brewers RF: ad cubs LF: ad cubs overall, i think the cubs lineup wins because the areas in which they excell, the excell greatly. the cubs have 3 top hitters in their lineup. i'd take lee, ramirez, and soriano over fielder, hardy, and hall, quite easily. as for pitching: sheets vs. zambrano: ad zambrano capuano vs. hill: ad hill (close) suppan vs. lilly: push bush vs. marquis: marquis (close) vargas vs. guzman????: ad vargas bullpen: brewers (close) i don't think it really matters how you configure the rotation comparison, the cubs are better, imo.