Yes, yes it is. Particularly when your pen is already strong. Totally agree. It's dumber than the Pierre trade for the Cubs. At least Pierre filled a need and we got him for a full season. The Brewers gave away one of their best trading chips for 2.5 months of a relief pitcher they didn't even particularly need. Need for what, a leadoff hitter who doesn't get on base enough? I'm one of the biggest Pierre bashers alive, so obviously I don't think he helped us. But we did need an everyday CF for a season, so on paper he did fill a need, unlike Linebrink for the Brewers. Trading top prospects for Pierre was a bad way to fill a need, but trading top prospects for Linebrink was a bad way to fill a non-need.