Personally, I think it was absolutely unnecessary. Personal insults are never harmless. More than anything, they reduce the value of your own argument. Personal insults drive down the value of this community. You class "you're making things up as you go along" as a personal insult? I take your point about the Cubs having an imperfect record when it comes to deciding which players to protect on the 40-man roster, but, unless you've heard a single dissenting opinion in this particular instance, someone that believes either that Nolasco should have been left off the roster or Pignatiello added, or both, then my point is still valid. Yes, implying that I was "making things up as I go along" is insulting, as you are trying to drive down someone else's reputation. It's slander. Not too different than calling someone a jerk. As to your earlier post, you commented on me making opinions based on seeing Nolasco once. For starters, I never qualified myself as a "scout," nor did I offer my opinion before it was asked. Now that I relook the thread, you're the one that asked me what I thought of them. I answered, and never did I imply that I had extensive experience watching them. I offered up what little insight I had based on my limited experience I had observing them. Nor did I ever say they should have protected Pigs or anything of that nature.