That seems unlikely since the Cubs have control of him through next year. Unless he is done for 2+ years or Kaplan thought he was going to be traded, there's no reason to say he has thrown his last pitch as a Cub. Kap is right. Because Prior is making $3.6 million this year, the least the Cubs can offer him in arbitration next year is $2.8 million. And the best case doesn't have him pitching rehab until next June. If the Cubs wanted to keep him, they wouldn't have let him accrue service time this year and leveraged that. By reinstating him to the major league roster's DL, they gave up that possibility. They only control him through '08 now. Prior will be non-tendered this winter and will sign a two-year "sign and hope" with someone else. I just hope it isn't the Cardinals. Let me count the ways this is wrong. 1) His contract is small compared to overall payroll. They have shown willingness to take fliers on injured pitchers in the past. 2) Do you have any source for your "best case scenario"? Or are you just using your medical expertise to predict how long he'll be out? 3) They had no choice but to let him accrue service time, if they had refused he would have won the grievance case easily, since he was clearly injured before being placed on a minor league roster. 4) Again, any source on Prior being non-tendered more reliable than your cristal ball? If the Cubs wanted to release Prior, why not do when it becmae clear he was out for the year, rather than putting him on the DL? Do you really believe that they would give him a year to sit on the DL and cut him as soon as he is ready to pitch? If they were really planning to get rid of him, why wouldn't they have done it at the beginning of the year? 1) $2.8 million might be a small fraction of payroll, but is way more than Miller or Dempster got to rehab. That doesn't even include the $3.6 million they're paying him to rehab this year. 2) Reports at the time of his surgery mentioned previous instances of this kind of repair and mentioned no competitive throwing for one year. 3) Is this your legal expertise? Prior's insistence that he was healthy pokes a huge hole in his grievance. I don't think you can just dismiss the Cubs' claim. 4) Why isn't Prior doing any rehab here? The Cubs are cutting bait. Even if they give him arbitration next year, he's a free-agent after 2008. If the initial reports about recovery time were true, why would the Cubs pay more of the downside with less hope of getting the upside? And do you think Prior would take a two-year deal from the Cubs like Miller or Dempster got when Prior is guaranteed $5 million for '08 and '09 if he goes the arbitration route. HE IS GONE!!! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH :twisted: