No , Ballesteros should have not hit in that situation , considering Counsell hasn’t showed any faith in him so far againts them . He got a walk , but that doesn’t mean it was the right call or the move that gave his team the best chance .
I think using Kelly and Shaw for Moises and PCA in those situations was the higher percentage move , especially with Pete when the tying run was at the plate .
Shaw is running like a 186 wrc againts lefties . PCA has been better this season so far , but pretty meh overall at 86. . Even if they bring a righty for Shaw I like the matchup better than Pete againts a lefty .
I edited my original post to talk about how good of a job Counsell has done so far this year overall . With that said it’s fair to question that decision last night IMO . Pete should not take important at bats late in games againts lefties at this point , simple as that .
it really doesn’t matter if the game is in April or September . They all count the same .