I'd switch Soriano and Castillo, despite the power differences.. Castillo is much more of an OBP guy than Soriano is..hell, I might even make it Todd Walker on the OBP/SLG team...and I'm not sure Wilson belongs with the high OBPers either..... Ah, hell, I'll just list my own.. high avg/low relative OBP guys, swing at a lot /good de C - Pudge Rodriguez 1B - Sean Casey 2B - Alfonso Soriano 3B - Shea Hillenbrand? SS - David Eckstein LF - Carl Crawford CF - Willy Taveras RF - Ichiro low avg/high obp, high slg guys/bad de C - Jorge Posada 1B - Richie Sexson 2B - Todd Walker 3B - Troy Glaus LF - Adam Dunn CF - Brad Wilkerson RF - Geoff Jenkins? It was tough to stick to all the qualifications, did my best though...paid more attention to the offensive stuff, but took defense into account when I could.