You missed that he hits for about as much power as Theriot, he'd be a disaster in a corner OF spot. In fact, all things considered he's remarkably like Jose Macias. 1) Everyone on the team doesn't have to hit for power. When you have Ramirez, Lee, Soriano, and Barrett you get plenty of power, it'd be nice to have some speed in the lineup that can get on base (Theriot and Guzman could provide that). Plus it'd give the opportunity to move Soriano out of the lead-off spot which everyone seems to want so badly. 2) Don't ever compare anyone to Jose Macias, it isn't fair. Macias has achieved his own level of sucktitude. Plus you can't compare him to Macias considering Macias has sucked for almost 8 years in the majors, and this guy has 83AB in the majors 3) How would he be a disaster in a corner OF spot? If I had a dollar for every time I heard someone say we should move a CF to a corner spot or a corner OF'er to CF over the last few years I'd be raking. Hell, people are throwing the idea around of trading for Teixeira and moving him to the OF and people seem okay with the idea, how would moving what Baseball America describes as Texas' best defensive outfielder to a corner spot be a disaster? He'd be a disaster because he does nothing but hit singles. You can't have a guy with a minor league IsoP of .080 in a corner OF spot. It's just way too hard to compensate elsewhere. Extra base hits are important. And besides, a sub .360 minor league OBP is nothing to write home about. As far as the comparison goes, take a look at Macias' minor league career on the baseball cube. Almost the exact same hitting line while playing at levels at similar ages. Guzman is 26 and has never put up an OPS above .760, he has the ceiling of a fifth outfielder.