Jump to content
North Side Baseball

raw

Community Moderator
  • Posts

    5,716
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    7

 Content Type 

Profiles

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Trade & Free Agent Rumors

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospect Rankings

Chicago Cubs News, Rumors & Analysis

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Chicago Cubs Fan Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by raw

  1. I think it was a tough spot to be in. Because every rational person knew the Bears weren't good enough. They knew the QB wasn't good enough, the coaching wasn't good enough, and the roster was hamstrung by bad contracts and lack of draft picks. All very valid reason to fire everyone after 2020. But I think the no losing seasons and 2 of 3 playoff years made it tough to fire them. There were a lot of disaster situations, but no disaster season from Nagy/Pace combo. Obviously, you shouldn't wait for a disaster to get rid of something that's not working, but I think the difference was that playoff game they were able to squeeze into. This is about the worst case scenario of the "high draft pick QB on rookie contract GO FOR IT" model. The Bears are easily on the worse end of this scale because of their imbalance in money spent on defense. You spend a ton on offensive line and weapons and the QB/OC/HC can't scheme ot motivate, you sway out whatever pieces and the talent is still there. The Bears didn't have enough offensive talent and were very heavy on defense so there was no quick fix. I agree that it would be hard to move on after missing the playoffs for the first time, but as you said, it was obvious that the 2019 and 2020 teams were not going on a deep playoff run. I would have loved to have been in the room for the meeting beween Pace/Nagy and ownership after 2020. "How are you going to fix it?" There was no good answer from Pace and Nagy except "gimme another vet QB, I have one I like. No, not that one, another one." How McCaskey and Phillips ended that meeting demanding progress from Pace/Nagy was just an astonishing decision unless neither one knows jack squat about the game. Watch the games and it should be obvious, but they blew that decision. This would have led to a 2020 with Foles entrenched as the starter going in. Foles would suck and eventually miss time to injury and the tank would have been on in completely natural form. The quick fix would have been what the Dolphins did. They didn't have the draft capital to trade for Tyreke Hill, but they could have gone for Amari Cooper and signed Armstead, a guard, Cedric Wilson or whoever else they did. I think most Bears fans would be ecstatic with that type of offseason. But that's wasn't really realistic in the Bears situation. I think the goal of this regime is to have some pieces is place on offense for 2023. Fields obviously is the biggest piece. But they're hoping Jenkins, Mooney, and probably at least 2 of the Day 2 picks this year (WR, OL) are big pieces as well. Guys like Patrick, Kmet, Pringle, and Borom could be smaller pieces. If those big pieces work out, then you're probably 1 more early draft pick and a FA signing on the OL away from being a pretty solid offense. 2023 offense: Qb- Fields RB- Herbert, whoever (Montgomery a FA) WR- Mooney, 2022 2nd round pick, 2023 2nd round pick? TE- Kmet LT- 2023 1st round pick? Should be top 10 LG- 2023 FA? C- Patrick RG- 2022 2nd/3rd round pick RT- Jenkins That's the makings of a talented young offense, with a couple vets on the OL and Mooney the vet at WR.
  2. Sucks that we we “went for it” the year we had an impossible schedule and are retooling the year we have an easy schedule I can't get over the decision to keep Nagy and Pace following 2020. It was so obvious at that time that it needed to be done, setting up Pace and Nagy to go for it one more time almost literally against all odds (hardest schedule, no QB, aging roster, OL problems, lack of weapons). Drafting Fields made no sense with those guys doing what they were doing. I'll stop here, cuz this is a bad cycle I get into! I think it was a tough spot to be in. Because every rational person knew the Bears weren't good enough. They knew the QB wasn't good enough, the coaching wasn't good enough, and the roster was hamstrung by bad contracts and lack of draft picks. All very valid reason to fire everyone after 2020. But I think the no losing seasons and 2 of 3 playoff years made it tough to fire them. There were a lot of disaster situations, but no disaster season from Nagy/Pace combo. Obviously, you shouldn't wait for a disaster to get rid of something that's not working, but I think the difference was that playoff game they were able to squeeze into.
  3. Can't believe Treylon Burks may slip to the 2nd round. I understand his limitations, but his play on the field says more than running around in underwear does. He's a big play waiting to happen whether you get the ball to him short, deep or intermediate. This is probably how I'd rank them as far as talent goes, but with the caveat that the Bears really need an outside WR, so if they pass on Dotson for Pickens or Watson, I'd understand completely. Dotson and Moore can play outside, though they are smaller, but may be better off playing all over the field similar to Mooney and maybe Pringle as well.
  4. IIRC, I think Cruikshank is very good defending against TEs, but yes, he's another DHC type. If we can sign a capable SS to start and then a minimum $$ FS to back up Jackson/5th safety, I'm fine with the safeties as a group. Do Bears normally have 5 safeties on their roster? 4 safeties is the norm. I believe the Bears have gone w/ 5 in the past for special teams purposes. Teez Tabor was listed as a CB, but played more safety than anything, so the Bears would have had Jackson, Gipson, DHC, Bush and Tabor last year at S.
  5. 1-4 is so tight too that I don't even know what seed I want the Bulls to get. Philly is the 4-seed right now, so that's a terrible 4-5 matchup. Milwaukee isn't any better. Ideal path to the ECF is Boston and Miami in some order, IMO. Obviously, both still really good teams (and Boston is red hot when they play their full roster) but I don't see the Sixers or Bucks as a team the Bulls can beat right now. Maybe they take a couple series for PAW and Caruso to get back to full strength and finding their spots in the rotation, and I'll take my chances then. But right now, I'm hoping they finish 6th if Boston or Miami ends up 3rd, and I hope the other finishes 2nd. I don't want play-in vs. Brooklyn at all, so 6th is the lowest I hope they go (should be safely in top 6).
  6. The threshold to count toward the comp pick formula is typically around 2.5Mil. I don't think it's a "set" amount, it's just based on percentage of contracts signed. Only players who sign contracts in the top 35% of AAV league-wide qualify for a comp pick. And with rookie deals, UDFA deals, vet minimums, etc. 65% of NFL contracts tend to be less than 2.5M AAV on any given year.
  7. Do you have me blocked?
  8. I suppose it's possible. Nagy said all the right things about Trubisky to get the job but then turned into a complete douche toward him. Would really make me question everything about Poles and Eberflus as talent evaluators.
  9. Looking thru some of the recently drafted QBs, the closest situation to what Fields will be in this year, may be Mariota in Tennessee. Drafted in 2015 New GM in 2016 inherited him New coach (kinda) as Mularkey was the interim during Mariota's rookie year Mariota also had some bad weapons. Rishard Matthews, Tajae Sharpe as his top WRs. Kendall Wright, who somehow always finds his way in a bad WR room, was there as well. Delanie Walker was then a pretty good TE. They did have Andre Johnson, but he was 35 and a shadow of his former self. They had 2 very good RBs with DeMarco Murray and Derrick Henry. Had a really young OL with Taylor Lewan , Quinton Spain, Ben Jones, Josh Kline, and rookie Jack Conklin all 27 or under. As a comparison... Mooney > any WR on TEN Matthews = Pringle (young WR, breakout-ish year with his previous team, cheap FA signing) Sharpe was a 5th round rookie that year, have to assume the Bears will draft a WR early so Advantage: Bears Wright was a 1st round bust, but did have a big 2nd year in TEN > Dazz No real equivalent to Johnson, hope it stays that way. But probably > St. Brown even at 35 Walker > Kmet, but not a huge difference Murray/Henry = Montgomery/Herbert. Just because RBs don't matter and Henry wasn't used much just yet. Conklin > Jenkins. Conklin was a top 10 pick. Slightly more talented than Jenkins a projected top 25 or so pick last year Lewan > Borom. Big difference in talent here Spain, Jones, Kline probably not much better than Whitehair, Patrick and whoever the RG will be. Jones is a solid C. Those other 2 are journeymen at best. Mariota did have his best season that year. 26-9 TD:INT ratio, 3400 passing yards, 61% completions, 95.6 QB rating. Given the circumstances, I'd take that neighborhood of that performance from Fields. Obviously, things didn't continue upward for Mariota so hopefully this year is where the comparison would end.
  10. Did you mean to link something? Definitely did mean to lol The big difference is that the Bills were able to draft Allen in that first year, whereas Justin already is a year in. The perspective will change if he puts up 2018 Josh Allen numbers in Year 2, as opposed to Year 1. Very unique situation where a team inherits a 2nd year QB from a GM that just traded a future pick to move up to get him. Teams don't usually allow lame duck GMs to mortgage the future for a QB.
  11. I think Poles definitely thought the market would pan out a certain way and it very clearly didn't, especially at WR. I think he thought Christian Kirk or MVS would be 6-8Mil/year type guys. I think he thought he'd be able to add solid OL help for value prices. That's the naivety of a new GM, I guess. All that is fine. I think the whole 1st, 2nd, 3rd wave stuff is truly where Poles intended to focus his time. But those values not matching what he thought players were worth threw him off, as his 2nd/3rd wave guys were going in the 1st wave that he wasn't willing to get into. That being said, he did get into the first wave for a DT that he was going to pay $13M/year for. My biggest issue with everything is that he wasn't willing to go in that first wave for offensive line help, to actually help his young QB. Seems like way too much focus is on guys who will stand up for their QB after taking a hard hit, instead of focusing on not getting his QB hit in the first place. He told us this line wasn't good enough, then didn't even try to re-sign the best player from that line last year. The 2nd best player on the OL was 40, so he's clearly not coming back. So, now you've added 1 replacement. Granted, it was the weakest piece on the OL, but the replacement isn't exactly a sure thing either. I'm fine with the approach. Not overpaying tier 1 guys is fine. Not going after 30+ year old players is fine. Short term deals on players with upside is fine. But there's nothing about the roster as of March 28, 2022 that is fine. It's terrible and it's not even terrible in a rebuilding way. It's not like the Jets or even Lions roster. It's a roster with no direction for a 22-year old franchise QB.
  12. A big who can defend and protect the rim in a trade for Vuc. I think Vuc is gone. I think a rim protector at the 5 and then a small ball 5 that can knock down outside shots to replace Vuc would be the ideal makeup with the rest of the team. Basically, a guy like Tristan Thompson for the starting lineup, and they still need a player like we were all talking about before the trade deadline.
  13. damn it took you this long? i think he grew up a huge bears fan too. i saw some story where it was the 2006 season that inspired him to take up football. It's always funny to me when the father/son are like completely different body types. Like different positions is not a big deal. But when you have big offensive lineman dad and the son is a WR (granted, DK is freaking huge as well) and a huge athletic difference, it kinda blows my mind. Like Ironhead and Cam Heyward. Ironhead was 5'11", Cam is 6'5". And then he has a brother in this draft (10 years younger) that's 5'11" like the dad. Like where the hell did Cam come up with 6 extra inches (pause).
  14. Bates still seems like a swing IOL guy at best. Think they need a solid swing T and then maybe a cut candidate at G before the draft. That would allow them to focus on one big OL draft pick, but with position versatility Jenkins, Whitehair, Patrick, Bates, Borom Swing T, Vet G, Rookie, Mustipher That's barely an acceptable top 9 I guess. But could have made a bigger investment above the Bates role and tried to let Whitehair get beat out. They signed Dakota Dozier yesterday, so that's probably your Vet Guard for the bench. He gave up 6 sacks and committed 6 penalties when he started in 2020 for the Vikings (he's terrible). Lot riding on Patrick and Bates being able to play and Jenkins/Borom developing into really good players, really fast.
  15. When you look at elite QBs they know where to place the ball to receivers who are not necessarily open. They seem to have the ability to throw the ball so that only the WR has the opportunity to catch it. Fields needs to be hyper-accurate with his throws if he's going to be an elite QB. Obviously, you need sticky-handed WR to make those catches too. While I don't want to discount Fields ability to grow into a more anticipatory passer I think the best version of him is gonna be more a see open throw passer than an anticipatory guy. If he miraculously becomes Rodgers, getting the ball out quickest in the league and creating separation with timing, that's amazing, but for all his talent that isn't his game right now. That's never going to be his game, and it doesn't really matter either. Mahomes isn't an anticipation thrower. Watson is not. I think they will focus a lot on him getting rid of the ball in camp, just so that he can develop that skill. But his bread and butter will be the ability to hang in the pocket (or escape the pocket) and waiting for the big play to happen.
  16. Hope the Bates thing happens. He's young enough (25) that he could be a long-term option at RG. I'd love for them to add a Will Fuller for cheap. I believe Browns have interest w/ Watson there, but I heard 5M+ incentives. And of course, I'm still down to trade for Brandin Cooks or Tyler Lockett (DK seems like a pipe dream).
  17. Yeah, I didn't want to imply that if Fields is good it won't matter. They are stacking the deck against him, big time. Putting a lot of stock into the coaching and scheme. I understand going with upside around the upside of Fields, but I'd like at least 1 sure thing on the line. That's why I wanted them to go hard after Laken Tomlinson. They seem to value people that "know the system" and he's become a guy that you put in the lineup and you don't have to worry about that spot. Even if they get Ryan Bates from Buffalo, you're still looking at tackles you aren't sure about, Whitehair who has been mediocre for a couple years, Lucas Patrick and Bates who have upside and tenacity you look for, but neither has ever been a full-time starter. Then you throw in the weapons and while Mooney is probably a sure thing with 1000 yards last year and working out with Fields all winter, I'd love a guy that could give them some solid reps if a rookie isn't ready to play right away. But as of now, this is probably the least talented offense in the NFL, outside of Houston, and they have the best lineman and WR of the 2 teams.
  18. A lot of WR have still taken time to adjust (guys like Deebo or Pittman) Theres too major win now teams with multiple 1st round picks before the Bears who badly need WR. Worst thing they can do is pigeon hole themselves. But right now there needs are pretty numerous so I guess it's not a concern? Deebo had 57-802 yards as a rookie. Pittman 40-503. Mooney was right in the middle of that yards-wise as a rookie. And I don't think a rookie has to be Justin Jefferson and JaMarr Chase right out the gate. I mean, it would certainly help and is sorely needed, but I think Mooney can give you a legit 1000-1200. If you can get a modest 500+ each out of Pringle and a rookie, you're already more productive than all of Robinson, Goodwin and Byrd were all of last year. Plus, I think part of performance is out of necessity. If Fields is good, someone will catch those passes. Of course, the issue is how good can Fields be with question marks at like 8 of the other 10 spots on offense with him.
  19. I like Jones a lot, actually. And this move may end up better than Ogunjobi in the long run anyway....because they should be looking to draft the most important positions anyway. In this defense, the important positions are: DE- they spend an early pick on when Quinn is gone LB- think they'll add a potential long term Mike in this draft DT- should look for a 3T early and Jones makes it so you don't have to thrust the rookie into the starting lineup right away, while Ogunjobi meant ignoring the position for 2-3 years. Now go spend money on OL. Sent from my SM-A115AZ using Tapatalk
  20. The 2 WR moves don't really move the needle for me much. I actually like Pringle a lot. He worked his way up the KC depth chart and was essentially their 3rd/4th weapon behind Hill/Kelce late in the year. But we have to put in perspective that his "breakout" season in 2021 was at at 28 and still less than 600 yards for a team that had like 2000 more yards passing than the 2021 Bears did. He's OK as a 3rd WR, but more ideal as a 4 WR who has a chance to work his way to a 3 like he did in KC. But it's a 1-year deal, so he's clearly not being looked at as a building block. Just a spot on the 53 in a rebuilding year. St. Brown is frankly, not good. He's a bottom of the roster player. He was the 5th WR and like the 9th or 10th option (behind RBs and TEs) in GB. While they were a good offense, remember this is a team that people have said "doesn't have enough weapons" for years with St. Brown on the roster that he couldn't crack the rotation of. He's a special teamer at best, who should not get reps over Dazz Newsome at this point.
  21. Love that move for him. The Bears should have traded him there at the deadline before they got Odell. I just personally felt bad for this dude playing on bad teams w/ bad QBs and Detroit was the team with the most interest. Wonder if they'd trade us Bobby Trees.
  22. Daniels got 3/26.5 and the guy they signed to replace him got 2/8. And he's supposedly a more nasty type of lineman, which Poles made clear he prefers. I think saving money and getting the type of player you prefer makes sense here. Daniels should have been a good got athletically for the scheme. I guess attitude (or even consistency) are being prioritized. This guy got ARob extension wrong last year, but I feel like maybe he has called other things and is maybe connected? He posted a video of Ogunjobi being blocked to the ground in last year's game vs. the Bears and captioned it with something like "getting bodied by the worst C in the league". Meanwhile, he completely ignored the fact that Daniels and Whitehair also gave him hits at the same time to knock him off balance helping Mustipher put him on the ground.
  23. I figured Grant for a Cordarrelle Patterson Bears deal. He got 2/10 from the Bears a few years ago (1/3 from Atlanta). I was expected 3/15 and would have been willing to go there to keep him in Chicago. Liked him as a gadget/speed player, but not a big loss if he's going to not consistently make it back to the 25 on kickoffs he runs deep out of the endzone.
  24. I love Tyrann Mathieu as a player/leader, but I can't get behind trading Mack because you wanted to allocate more resources to the offense then probably spend 25M annually on Ogunjobi and Mathieu.
  25. JC Tretter cut, probably top 5 Center in the league. La'el Collins likely going to be cut, a good starting RT (has G experience, could conceivably play LT too) The Bears could still put together a really good OL and do it while getting multiple comp picks. Could also be going after Terron Armstead as well, maybe waiting for the market to come down a bit. I actually like the approach at WR. Like I said earlier, Cooks could come available via trade or perhaps a cut. I love Will Fuller as a cheap 1-year flier guy, who's a great fit with Fields (game similar to Olave). There's also some cheap slots available in the 2nd/3rd tier that I like. I will say that I wish Poles' 1 big signing in Tier 1 was OL. A couple guys I wanted were cheaper than Ogunjobi, who I like, but don't love. I love a couple guys in the draft (Wyatt, Winfrey), but understandable if Poles thinks those guys are too far out of reach at 39 (or is focused on WR/OL early in the draft).
×
×
  • Create New...