Jump to content
North Side Baseball

raw

Community Moderator
  • Posts

    5,716
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    7

 Content Type 

Profiles

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Trade & Free Agent Rumors

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospect Rankings

Chicago Cubs News, Rumors & Analysis

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Chicago Cubs Fan Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by raw

  1. I think if Cleveland can't get Garoppolo, they'd definitely look to trade up to #3. There's really no point in having all those picks without coming out of it with a QB and the best defensive player. They don't have a ton of major needs, at least not as many as they have early draft picks. Pass rusher and QB are their 2 biggest needs. After that, they could use a WR, TE and another CB....but they could get by with what they have and certainly could add talent with their other picks. I look at trade downs a couple different ways. There's the trade down to the 6-8 range. Then there's the trade down to 9-13 range. At 6-8, you may be able to get a lot of the guys you would be looking at with the 3rd pick. I see the options for the 3rd pick as (in no order): Solomon Thomas, Jonathan Allen, Deshaun Watson, Mitch(ell) Trubisky, Jamal Adams, Malik Hooker, or Marshon Lattimore. Figure Garett goes 1, so at 3 the Bears should have their pick of all but 1 of those guys. And then at 8, at least 1 of those guys would be left. At 9-13, I think you could still have one of those QBs on the board (Watson most likely). I think Hooker or Lattimore could still be on the board, depending on how team's feel about their injury situations and if a RB or TE goes. And then I think it opens up the board for OJ Howard, Mike Williams/Corey Davis, or the 2nd CB or 3rd edge rusher. The one caveat here is if the Niners don't want a QB at 2, then they'll basically have neon signs to sell their draft slot.
  2. I think the same thing about the QB position. I think the Bears will either move up into the late 1st to secure a 5th year for one of the top 4 QBs if they are still around. And if not, they'll move down and take one of the senior bowl QBs (Peterman or Webb). As for the rest of the draft, it's interesting. I'm a big Taywan fan. I think he can be the best separation WR in this class and he's great with the ball in his hands. I'd kill for Jones at that point. One of my favorite prospects in the draft, and he has an argument for top CB in this class. Agree with your assessment of Thompson. I'd probably want to go S a little earlier, as I still don't think the position is upgraded enough....but if it played out this way I wouldn't be upset.
  3. Floyd and Whitehair were the only guys Pace drafted last year that he was connected to pre-draft. The Watson, non-meeting is interesting. On one hand it could be a smokescreen. Pace has talked a lot this offseason about the importance of experience and winning in college as a QB. But he just spent 15M on a QB for 2017 who is certainly going to start, and Watson looks to me like the most pro-ready QB of this group. I think if Pace's idea is to have a QB sit for a year, it's going to be Trubisky (1-year as a starter) or Mahomes (raw, huge upside, but gimmicky offense), or he'll take a guy like Davis Webb or Peterman in the 2nd or 3rd. I think the last is the most likely scenario. Pace is going to hedge his bets on Glennon for 2017, draft a guy (I'd watch for a trade back to the mid-second to take Peterman) to develop, and then if necessary, go after a QB in the 2018 draft. The 2018 QB class looks like it could be pretty good. Also, I love all those RBs late. Really like McGuire. He was bigger than I expected at the combine and should be able to hold up between the tackles if it comes to that. But he has excellent hands as a receiver and can pass block a little too.
  4. I think the Gilmore preference is based mostly on his ability to get turnovers. Gilmore had 5 INTs this past year (14 career in 5 years). Bouye only had 1 last year and 6 in his career. I personally think Bouye is the better CB. He'll allow fewer plays against him. But Gilmore will make bigger plays on the ball. Rather have the guy that can cover better, but either is fine.
  5. Keep in mind Hooker will not be able to workout before the draft, will miss all of rookie and minicamps, and will likely start camp on the PUP. He's also only a 1-year starter.
  6. Give me the Stillers and Cardinals.
  7. I think they'll spend to get their elite defensive talent. And yeah, OJ Howard is one of the players I had in mind at 11.
  8. I think if the Bears let Jeffery go part of it will be because of WR he is. Jeffery is a great WR. But he's big and doesn't create a ton of separation. If Pace lets him walk, I think it will be to replace him with guys who are plus route runners with speed that create separation and can run after the catch. That's the type of WR the Saints have typically gone after, including when Pace was there. And the interest in Jimmy Garoppolo fits the narrative as he's from an offense that features quick WRs who create separation and get the ball on the move. Same goes for Mitch Trubisky, who recent rumors have the Bears very interested in. I can appreciate fit to some extent, but it seems like a wasted opportunity on Pace's part, and the Cooks value just feels off. I'd rather explore FA and mid round draft fits in thae case they move on from Jeffery. I know what you mean. And I hate the thought of getting rid of Jeffery just to create a hole on a team with a lot of holes. But getting Cooks would provide a semblance of lateral movement at the WR position, just with a completely different look that may benefit Pace's vision. And this is about the only way to not take a huge hit in talent at the position.
  9. I think if the Bears let Jeffery go part of it will be because of WR he is. Jeffery is a great WR. But he's big and doesn't create a ton of separation. If Pace lets him walk, I think it will be to replace him with guys who are plus route runners with speed that create separation and can run after the catch. That's the type of WR the Saints have typically gone after, including when Pace was there. And the interest in Jimmy Garoppolo fits the narrative as he's from an offense that features quick WRs who create separation and get the ball on the move. Same goes for Mitch Trubisky, who recent rumors have the Bears very interested in.
  10. I think I'd rather take my choice of impact player at 3 and possibly at QB at 36. Though, it largely depends on your evaluation of Garappolo. If you're really sold on Garappolo, a lot makes sense, though in your scenario, the Cooks thing can still be totally independent of that. I'm not sold on Garoppolo, but where there's smoke there's fire and it sure seems like Pace has been sold on him since his days in NOLA.
  11. So, would anyone do a trade of the #3 pick Brandin Cooks and the 11th overall pick (maybe a couple other picks exchanged, with NO giving up more value)? There was the rumor late in the season that Brandin Cooks could be on the trade block from New Orleans. Cooks made a big stink after a game in which he had 0 targets, and the rumors started. But they could be pretty legit. Cooks is a FA after 2017, and he was surpassed by rookie, Michael Thomas as the team's leading WR. The Saints also have Willie Snead who has put up strong numbers 2 years in a row. The Saints are constantly up against the cap and there is little chance they pay Cooks #1 WR money when he was a legitimate 3rd option for many games this past season. For the Saints, they get something for Cooks instead of letting him walk after the season. At 11, they probably just miss out on the top defensive game-changing talents in the draft. So, if they could move up to #3 they could get their pick of any defensive prospect other than Garrett. They have huge needs at DE (Solomon Thomas), CB (Marshon Lattimore), LB (Foster), and could use a S to replace the bust signing that has been Jairus Byrd (Hooker, Adams), and could get their hands on a player that otherwise won't be there if they stand pat. Trading Cooks also gives them a means to move up in the draft without giving up another high draft pick. For the Bears, Cooks would provide an alternative to re-signing Alshon Jeffery. He'd be cheap for this year, before you'd have to re-sign him to a similar deal as Jeffery. But Cooks has been completely healthy the last 2 years, has great speed and big play ability. Pace was with the Saints when they drafted Cooks and presumably likes him as a player. Not to mention there should be a natural opening for trade talks with Pace and his former team. Unfortunately though, this trade only makes sense for the Bears if they have already traded their 2nd for Jimmy Garoppolo or signed Kirk Cousins. But if the Bears are dead set on not paying Jeffery the money he wants and don't love any of the QB prospects, I think I'd be OK with a haul of Garoppolo, Cooks, #11 and a 4th round pick for #3, #36, and a 2018 conditional pick.
  12. So tired of talking about the championship drought. I mean, I get it......The cubs haven't won a championship in 108 days.
  13. Re-signed Alshon Jeffery Brian Hoyer Deonte Thompson Sam Acho Cornelius Washington FA Signings CB, AJ Bouye, Houston TE, Jack Doyle, Indianapolis S, Duron Harmon, New England DT, Ian Williams, San Francisco Draft 3- Mitch Trubisky, QB, North Carolina 36- Adoree Jackson, CB, USC 67- Obi Melifonwu, S, UConn 109- Taiwan Taylor, WR, Western Kentucky 115- Dalvin Tomlinson, DL, Alabama 148- Daeshon Hall, OLB, Texas A&M 224- Elijah McGuire, RB, UL Lafayette QB Brian Hoyer, Mitch Trubisky, Connor Shaw RB Jordan Howard, Jeremy Langford, Ka'Deem Carey, Elijah McGuire WR Cameron Meredith, Taywan Taylor, Deonte Thompson, WR Alshon Jeffery, Kevin White, Daniel Braverman TE Zach Miller, Jack Doyle, Daniel Brown, Mycole Pruitt LT Charles Leno Jr., LG Josh Sitton, C Cody Whitehair, Hroniss Grasu RG Kyle Long, Eric Kush, RT Bobby Massie, DE Eddie Goldman, Cornelius Washington, NT Ian Williams, Dalvin Tomlinson DE Akiem Hicks, Jonathan Bullard OLB Willie Young, Sam Acho, Daeshon Hall OLB Pernell McPhee, Leonard Floyd, ILB Jerrell Freeman, John Timu ILB Nick Kwiatkoski, Danny Trevathan*, CB AJ Bouye, Cre'Von LeBlanc, Bryce Callahan CB Deiondre' Hall, Adoree Jackson, Kyle Fuller S Obi Melifonwu, Deon Bush, S Duron Harmon, Adrian Amos, DeAndre Houston-Carson
  14. A small part of me wouldn't be super upset at Jeffery walking. With Meredith (who looks like a keeper at this point) and Jeffery on the outside, that's a couple of big targets, but neither of which creates great separation. Throw in White, and if he gives this team anything, he's another big target. While he's faster than those other 2, he's not a big separation type of WR either. I'd be intrigued by adding a couple of really fast/shifty WRs to run around in the middle of the field and deep (ala Edelman, Hilton, Brown and the like). FA wise, Kenny Stills is out there. While not a great WR, always been a big play guy who had a good year this season and is still just 25 years old. Also, you could add a guy in the draft with some speed while still having the outside size with Meredith and White, and also having a ton of money to do whatever at CB. But unfortunately, the Bears aren't in the position to let talented young players walk away for nothing.
  15. Bannon is the literal devil so......
  16. The number 3 pick gets a hell of a lot more than the 16th, like a difference of $11m guaranteed and $15m in total value. If your pick at number 3 doesn't work out, it's going to hurt. Nice way to frame 11M over 4 years. Less than 3M per year. It's not going to hurt financially at all.
  17. Yeah, the projections you're going off of are random internet sites that have no bearing on NFL teams' draft boards. I'm not claiming I'm worthy of being a super scout or an NFL GM, but I have 2 QBs in my personal top 15 prospects (Watson 4-5, IIRC and Trubisky at like 13-14). Either of them would be worthy of the #3 pick over a 3rd DL (for a 3-4 team that runs 60% nickel) who has a bum shoulder, or a safety, or a 4th pass rusher. And I think you're grossly overestimating the "setback" from drafting a QB. They don't get paid very much on rookie deals anymore. And if the guy you draft can't play, you can tell pretty early. Buffalo didn't get set back by using the 16th pick on EJ Manuel. They've been better since Manuel (granted not with him playing). Same goes for the Skins w/ RG3 and Dolphins w/ Tannehill, Jets w/ Smith. Those QBs have mostly failed (not quite Tannehill yet), but their teams have competed for or been in playoff spots with them not being very good. Plus, there's the whole fact of what are the Bears being set back from? Cant' get any worse than 3-13. Pussyfooting around with the QB position for another year also means it probably won't get much better, or at least not good enough for it to matter. Tyrod Taylor or Tony Romo probably makes this a 9-win 1st round elimination team at best for 2 years at most. Then you go into 2019 still with no QB and nothing worthwhile to show for it anyway. Might as well throw away 2 years on the #3 overall pick and at least have a chance of a long-term solution.
  18. Can you point me to where Fox has said this? Also, there's nothing saying the Bears have to take a guy at 3 and absolutely have to play him. I think they do get into the Romo talks or the Taylor negotiations and even if they bring one of those guys in, they could very well still take a QB at #3. You play the vet QB as long as the team has a shot at competing, then if things go south, let the kid play. Coaches inherit young QBs all the time. Rams, Broncos (granted, odd situation), and likely the Jags have hired coaches inheriting young QBs just this month.
  19. Mike Glennon also sucks. Oh as does Jay Cutler, who you need to seriously get over trying to keep as a thing. I'm not advocating keeping Jay. But he's on a contract that allows for him to be cut at any point with no true cap hit. That alone has value for us right now. Especially if you don't think one of these QBs is worth the 3rd pick. It doesn't make any sense that you don't want to take a flyer on a QB later, where you site wanting to find a guy that can play. Yet, are willing to reach on one at 3, where its obvious none of them are BPA at THAT spot, nor know for sure(even remotely) that any of THIS group is an actual franchise type. Plus, as has been mentioned, its highly unlikely that the Pace/Fox tandem take one at 3, since its unlikely they'll be of much impact in a very important season for each of them. A later pick allows POSSIBLE development, and flexibility moving forward to using another much higher pick on one. You're speaking as if this stuff is fact. It's not "obvious" none of the QBs are BPA at the 3rd pick. Even if it that part was obvious, it is FACTUAL that QB is the most important position on any football team anywhere on Earth. So, reaching for the most important position in sports is certainly more beneficial than taking the BPA at say, safety, if both players work out. And if the player you pick doesn't work out, the reason won't be because it is a reach....but because the GM sucked at drafting, the coaching staff sucked at developing, or a combination thereof. I also don't know where you're getting your "highly unlikely" thing from. I think this season is much more important to Fox than it is to Pace. Pace just drafted the 2nd leading rusher in the league, a lineman with pro bowl upside as soon as next year, a potential double digit sack edge rusher, the year after drafting a pro bowl potential DL and starting S. I don't think Pace is going to be fired without having a chance to take a franchise QB, especially after he inherited Cutler's contract situation and a team at rock bottom. And strangely enough, Fox doesn't make draft picks.
  20. Mike Glennon also sucks. Oh as does Jay Cutler, who you need to seriously get over trying to keep as a thing.
  21. I wouldn't even consider that move. Pats produced system type? No confidence it translates elsewhere, I guess? I have gone round and round trying to figure out my ideal 2017 QB situation.... 1. Sign Taylor and take a developmental guy in the 3rd or 4th 2. Get Garoppolo for a 2nd.(Have this over option 3 strictly because he can play immediately) 3. Resign Hoyer, get Trubisky, Kizer, or Mahomes at 36.(Watson too, but truly think he's safely off the board) 4. Trade down in the 1st, to 10-15 range, accumulate picks, and still get 1 of those 4 QBs, at that spot. 5. Sign Romo, after he's been cut. Draft a guy in the 3rd or 4th. Developmental QBs in the 3rd or 4th don't typically work out. All the options that include a 3rd or 4th round pick, would be better served if the Bears either go after Mahomes at 36 or just take an actual player with one of those top 110 picks with a chance to be something. Also, Romo is dead. If you get him (and pay him several millions of dollars) you'd need a much better backup QB than a mid-round pick, who is likely going to play several games for a team that will likely be really bad because of this fact. The trade down makes no sense. Why not just actually make a pick at QB at 3 instead of settling for 1 of 4 who may/may not be there?
  22. The thing about Garoppolo isn't that he's necessarily terrible. He's only started twice in 3 years and he's been pretty good when he's been on the field (over 100 QB rating), but he only has 94 career passes thrown. He would cost the 36th pick (at least) and he's also a FA after the 2017 season. Which means you either have to negotiate a contract extension (along with or right after the trade) to pay a guy 18M/year that you don't even know can actually play. Based on the contracts of Tyrod Taylor and Brock Osweiler, 18M is the going rate for a likely middle of the road at best QB that doesn't have much starting experience. And this doesn't get into the unsuccessful history of A) teams trading for Patriots QBs that have looked good in limited duty (Cassel, Mallett) or B) the Bears trading for another team's QB instead of picking their own. Oh yeah, and he could actually be terrible.
  23. Brett Anderson, for some reason, has been one of my favorite potential Cubs targets for about 4 years now.
  24. Rockies are an interesting trade partner. There's been a lot of discussion about them adding more bullpen arms and they're obviously trying to compete now. Plus, based on their recent decision-making, it's an good opportunity to have our FO run circles around theirs. Kyle Freeland and maybe Jeff Hoffman could be available. Both are fairly well regarded, however both have lost a bit of luster. Freeland is more likely and its split on whether he's in the pen or rotation long-term. That being said, he has a deceptive arm angle and a four pitches so there's something to work with. Yeah, I proposed a Rondon, Szczur and a prospect for Hoffman and we take Parra off their hands, but that was before Jay. But I think something still could be done there. Uehara makes Rondon potentially available. And there's still some decent RPs available to replace him. I don't know that either Hoffman or Freeland are going to make that rotation.
×
×
  • Create New...