You just don't get it...this is not a very good analogy as it relates to the current scenario. Yeah, I don't get it. Bitter distaste for a guy that had the nerve to play on another team and beat the Cubs. And stopped to watch a homerun. OMG! No Cubs have ever done that (or, for example, shown up opponents by doing a "hop" after every homerun)! I hate him for life and want to boo him and (insert gay joke here)! All this vitriole has very little to do with him possibly no longer being an effective player. i think you'd be surprised. most people on this board don't want him on the cubs because he sucks at baseball. Yeah, but they're not the ones pissing and moaning. oh i've pissed and moaned plenty, and not because edmonds used to play for the cardinals or is gay. I feel the same way, but while Edmonds is bad, think about this: 1. Pie hasn't been slighted by this. The pooch has been screwed regarding Pie for weeks now. In fact, he may be better off in Iowa, because he sure wasn't getting any AB's here. 2. As woeful as Edmonds OPS was in San Diego, Johnson's has been worse in May, and the two are trending in opposite directions. IMO, Johnson = Edmonds. Neither should be playing in front of Pie, but that point is really moot. So really, signing Edmonds doesn't make any difference whatsoever, save maybe that he and Reed could make a decent platoon, and it could get Kosuke moved up the order. All of this hand wringing over Edmonds is just stupid. I don't care for the guy, but some of these people who are acting as if their child's rapist just joined the team need to grow the hell up. What most of us are upset about is that Pie isn't playing. While the Edmonds signing reinforces that, any hope that Felix was going to get his shot this year was false, and deep down we all know that. Yes, Edmonds sucks. But he doesn't really make the team any worse than it was, and the Cubs aren't paying him squat. Expressing our distaste for Edmonds isn't going to make Hendry or Lou and less dense. Let's move on, it's done.