I'll say one thing in defense of Tucker. When they brought him in the idea was to run the Lovie defense for continuity, and he did do that. The first 3 games were definitely good. Then the injuries and the deterioriation -- we all know the story. He hasn't run his own defense here. You can argue that he didn't make the right adjustments during the season, and you are correct. But he wouldn't be able to completely switch to his defense right in the middle of the season. He would need an offseason to install his defense, and it sounds like that's what Trestman is going to give him: a chance to run his scheme from the start of the offseason, with personnel decisions being made in conjunction with his scheme. Will it work? I don't have a lot of confidence, but that's got to be the argument for Tucker. He gets a year to do something other than be Lovie's shadow.