Josh Hamilton was never a part of the organization in any real sense. He was drafted with a pre-draft agreement to send him to the Reds. There was never an option to keep him. Casey McGehee has had 178 ABs in the majors this year. In his minor league career he posted a .283/.340/.417/.757 line. Those aren't numbers that make you think he's going to OPS .911 in the majors. Let's see how he continues to hit the rest of the year and into next season. As for Fukudome, there is a lot to his ability over and above how he finishes his swings. He has quite a few positive attributes that make a lot of sense as to why the scouts felt strongly about him. And keep in mind, the Cubs scouts weren't the only ones who liked him. I believe the White Sox and Padres had similar, if not larger, offers on the table for him when he chose the Cubs. And no, our minor league system isn't one of the top 5 or so in the majors, I'll agree (all the teams you listed are at or near the top of the rankings). But, since Tim Wilken has taken over the farm has improved greatly - to the point where it could be ranked in the teens at the start of next year. Those players are low in the system right now (mostly in AA and A ball) but there's plenty of reason to be very optimistic about the farm system. And I think you could make an argument that Zambrano is one of the better pitchers in the league right now and, if he keeps rebounding like he has been, Soto could still be one of the top catchers in the game. I also forgot Marmol in my list - a guy who the past couple of years has been one of the elite relievers in the game.