That's some pretty strong criticism for a guy who BA rated as the 23rd, 38th, and 12th best minor leaguer in baseball from 97-99. He had some solid numbers in the minors, pitched well in very limited ML action in 98 (at 21), struggled some in 99 (at 22), and then was horrid in 67 ML innings in 2000 (at 23). He did need a mechanical (and apparently psychological) overhaul in 2001, but the makings of a very good pitcher were certainly there beforehand. I wouldn't credit Wilken with drafting the best pitcher in baseball, but to give him no credit for identifying talent in Halladay, or to actually criticize him for making the pick, is over the top I think. Barney's a 2-3 WAR player during his cost controlled years. I don't think he should be held up as a great success of the farm system, but he doesn't suck. As a 4th round pick, I think he was a decent selection by Wilken.