Personally, I love the emotional yo-yoing many do with various players when they struggle. One week he's great, the next he's shark bait, etc. Trade him for peanuts, DFA him, send him to AAA. Where's the hate for Piniella keeping Rich in a crappy spot? While Rich may have thrown the pitches, it was clear that he had nothing. In such a situation, it is incumbent upon the manager to make a change to improve his team's chance of winning. The bottom line is that Rich struggled yesterday, but he wasn't as awful as many make him out to have been (I was at the game, and I DVRed it, too). Hindsight is always 20/20, but I would have pulled Rich in the fifth inning (I annoyed my wife by commenting to this effect repeatedly). He was tired, struggling with command, and facing the heart of the Nationals order (such as it is) in Zimmerman, Young and Kearns with 1 out and runners on second and third. That was the right time to replace him, regardless of Lou's obsession about the impact on the 11 man bullpen. Bring in Wuertz to face Zimmerman, Young and Kearns, and you have a good chance to end the inning with no damage. Zimmerman is prone to the strikeout this year -- 60 K's in 369 AB, and his splits against RH pitching indicate vulnerability (51 K and a line of .218/.266/.380). Granted, historically, Young is better from the left side of the plate, and if you are really worried about that, you walk Young by giving him nothing good to hit. You then face Kearns, who has a line of .243/.308/.342 against right-handed pitching. Or you could walk Zimmerman, intentionally, giving up another baserunner for Young and go for the DP with a tiring Rich Hill who was giving up fly-ball after fly-ball yesterday. Good managing is about giving your team the best chance to succeed and using the players you have available to best advantage. Lou did not do this on Wednesday, and it cost Hill and the Cubs a grand slam and turned a winnable ball game into a rout. Admittedly, the Cubs scored no runs, in the end, and perhaps it wouldn't have mattered. But, at the time, no knew the end result of the game, so taking the best percentage option to get out of the inning seems like the right course of action. 2-0 is better than 6-0, last time I checked.