Without looking it up, I have to guess Dempster's walk rate is at least similar to Wood's, if not worst. I don't get why Wood can't close because he walks people, but Dempster can. I agree that Ryan should stay there for now. Personally I think the swingman 7th/8th inning role is far more important than the closer. On an ideal team, your closer doesn't walk anyone; nor do your starters. Of course, we live in an imperfect world, and the Cubs are ... more imperfect than you or I would like. I happen to agree that the 7th/8th inning role is more important than the 9th. Far too often, there's a mess that need's cleaning in the 7th or 8th. Frankly, I think you should use your best reliever in the most difficult situations, rather than in some defined "closer's" role. It does you little good to have a Billy Wagner or Eric Gagne for the 9th if you can't keep the lead in the 8th.