I'd have to wonder what that record would look like if he didn't wear armor on his elbow. If someone could show how many of those HBPs hit his body proper rather than his elbow, I'd like to see it. Hmmm.... 1) Eddie Collins 2) Ryno 3) Rogers Hornsby 4) Napoleon Lajoie 5) Biggio or ....hate to say it Joe Morgan Good list...but I think Morgan has to be higher than 5. The guy was an offensive force of nature for many years and has a legitimate case to be considered the greatest Post-WW2 2B. As for Biggio's chances, he'll make the HOF, no question asked. It's difficult to assess whether he's going to be a first ballot guy, though. He received MVP votes in five years, 1994 (16th), 1995 (10th), 1997 (4th), 1998 (5th), and 1999 (12th). The only seasonal meaningful (in the eys of HOF voters) offensive categories he ever led were Runs (twice, 1995 and 1997), Doubles (three times, 1994, 1998, 1999, and also the leader among active 2B), and Stolen Bases (once, 1994). He also leads second basemen in singles. One curious thing that holds him back is that he is 12th in outs made over his career and first among active second basemen. Odd. However, you have to remember that the following words will be used in any given puff piece that will come up when his career ends: Hustle Gritty Intangibles Guts Scrappy Clutch Toughness Feisty Pest Enthusiasm Gumption Will Heart Role Model Overachiever Infectious Tough Tenacious Middle aged sports writers everywhere might jump all over voting for him. He might not be the ideal candidate for first ballot, but the potential is most certainly there.