I dont think I can say no fast enough. really, wow, i understand the love of Murton's potential but you get a chance at a player of Ichiro's caliber you have to take it- i think you might be overvalueing Murtons Potential as well as Marshall and Gallagher- they are young unproven commodities- I think i couldnt say yes fast enough( if Ichiro wanted to sign an extension) As TT said, he is one of the most overrated players in the game. I'm not denying he's good, because he is, but he's certainly not worth that package. First of all, even though this will only be his 7th season in the big leagues, he'll be 34 at the end of this season. Furthermore, his numbers (once you look past his batting average, a non-so-important stat in itself) aren't anything truly special. Here are his career (in the MLB) numbers (obp/slg/ops) 376/.438/.814 And actually, he hasnt broken an .800 ops since 2004. By comparison, Matt Murton's career numbers are: .370/.462/.832