Would Guillen have made the play. He isnt the best SS around. No, Guillen doesn't get to that ball, IMO. If you get a chance to see the replay on that one, watch what happens to Polanco. I was like you guys, the first 3 or 4 times i saw the play, I was like how did the Neifury get to that ball (then i stupidly remembered he is a Supernatural force and it is not meant for mere mortals to understand his power). Polanco got absolutely crushed on the turn, like a QB getting hit on the blind side. Not every 2b would have stood in there and taken that kind of shot for a teammate. Bill Hall was trying his darndest to stop it. Kudos to him for taking that blow and getting the throw out in time. I agree with you, Polanco actually made the tougher part of that play. In typical Neifi fashion, he actually made it look harder than it was. He was in great position to catch the ball and stopped a sharp hit, but it's not like it took a lot of range.