no i don't believe all players produce equally during clutch situations. i think better hitters produce better in clutch situations than worse hitters. i don't think arod is worse than average in clutch situations. i think every time he does fail (appx 65-70% of the time) it gets way overblown, and when he does succeed, it tends to be forgotten. for what it's worth, here's arod's "clutch" splits. they're pretty close to what his career numbers are, which i think tends to be the case for most players. Clutch Stats
I Split G GS PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB IBB SO HBP SH SF ROE GDP SB CS BA OBP SLG OPS
+-+------------+----+----+-----+-----+----+----+---+---+---+----+----+---+----+---+---+---+---+---+----+---+-----+-----+-----+-----+
2 outs, RISP 716 896 744 201 31 2 36 284 136 28 170 16 0 0 11 0 .270 .394 .462 .856
Late & Close 1103 1509 1310 361 66 4 81 236 164 17 308 21 4 10 16 34 .276 .363 .518 .881
Tie Game 1429 2205 1876 567 112 5 133 358 280 15 404 30 7 12 26 47 .302 .399 .580 .979
Within 1 R 1648 3885 3324 1012 191 11 236 641 465 32 693 58 14 24 45 95 .304 .397 .582 .979
Within 2 R 1705 5108 4415 1319 238 14 294 827 581 40 927 66 15 31 59 120 .299 .386 .559 .945
Within 3 R 1724 5995 5197 1576 284 18 358 1006 661 47 1080 82 16 39 70 138 .303 .388 .571 .959
Within 4 R 1733 6596 5726 1741 318 22 397 1127 713 49 1206 90 16 51 77 153 .304 .387 .575 .962
Margin > 4 R 660 1193 1055 330 48 4 68 223 107 10 201 17 0 14 15 35 .313 .381 .559 .940