Clarify this. Given the oppotunity, you'd take Paul over Rose? No, id put them on the floor together, as that would be unstoppable. I figured in the knicks fans' alternate reality they had the option of both Lin and Paul, but given paul's contract needs and the fact they would have to trade for him, they were "blessed to just have Lin, the cap room, and Shumpert/Fields; and not just Paul". Perhaps i misunderstood their thread. Between the two, Id take Rose (to start a franchise with) because he is younger and Paul has suffered a knee injury. If it were a one of season, it would depend on the composition of the rest of the team. I would have never dreamed that Rose could even be argued over CP3 after just three years in the league. Its pretty remarkable that you can successfully make that argument. I also think there are areas that Rose may improve before his quickness starts to decline, whereas CP3 is probably at his summit right now.