I take it you're in a keeper league. If McLouth and Doumit didn't have such a sketchy offensive history, it might not be a bad deal, but they're only breaking out this year, who knows what will happen next year. I know you can say the same for Geo, but he was expected to produce like this this year, McLouth and Doumit weren't. And Sizemore? That's really the icing on the cake for that one