I soured on Soto a couple years ago. Even after his great bounce back campaign I didn't expect him to sustain that level of production. It could be wise to hang on to him to see if he can build his value back up after a rough 2011, I would think. I think Marmol should go simply because of the uncertaintly behind his reliability, health, and his ridiculous penchant for inconsistency. Trade him while you can wrap a pretty bow around his K totals and hope people ignore the fact he's the most volatile closer in the game right now before more people take notice this season, IMO. I think you trade Dempster whenever. Trade him now a team gets a full year out of him vs. a half year, but Dempster isn't the kind of guy teams need a full year out of. He definitely fits the "We need a reliable mid rotation guy to help bolster the starting 5" mold, which a lot of team tends to go after at the deadline. Even if he puts up league average numbers, he might yield a similar return at the deadline than he would now. I say trade him whenever they feel is best, just so long as he is, in fact, traded for something Byrd should be one of the easiest pieces to move. He's still productive, one more year, very affordable contract. He won't bring back a big return, but I think trading him now brings back a better return than later, personally.