I forgot about Stenerud and Blanda. If you support them being in, though, I think you have to support Vinatieri - if for no other reason than great consistency. Vinatieri is 15th all-time in field goal % and has been kicking longer than any other kicker ahead of him other than Jason Hanson, Matt Stover and John Carney - three kickers I'd argue could also eventually be in. Stenerud had a career FG% of 66.8% and Blanda had a career FG% of 52.4%. Vinatieri is .1% behind Blanda in extra point % and a few percentage points ahead of Stenerud. He's also 15th all-time in points scored - with mostly guys I'd have in consideration for the hall of fame ahead of him (including Blanda and Stenerud). I'm not going to argue Stenerud and Blanda belong in there because it doesn't look like they should, at least not compared to today's better kickers. Vinatieri's led the league twice in FG% and once in points and he's in the middle of active kickers in FG%. He'll be up there in career points, but his stats don't scream HOF to me so he's going to get in on his clutch kicks if he does. The Anderson/sen's definitely belong though. Oh, and 9 minute TD drives are awesome. Hold on Miami.