While I understand your point, I think that there are two places where I disagree: 1) I think the Cubs can compete as soon as 2012, depending on the available resources and being able to make a few key moves. This means that the remaining peak years will be extremely valuable to making this happen. As we've seen twice from St Louis, all you have to do is make the playoffs - anything can happen from there. 2) While Pujols will inevitably start to decline during this contract, he's starting from a peak as one of the 5-10 best hitters of all time. Even declining production from Albert will still be very good until near the end of the contract. Compete is one of those terms that mean different things to different people. To some, it means automatically become the hands on favorite for the division. In reality, compete means just that. Be good enough to be in the playoff conversation all season long. My thing is how much money do we want to spend to compete? Do we want to have a massive spending spree, sign Pujols/Fielder+Aramis+Wilson so that we're back on top for another 2-3 years before we get old and useless again, and hope that enough prospects pan out to stay competitive at that time? I agree, I would sign Pujols and get those 2-3 peak years and hope for the best the rest of the way, but then how do we want to conduct the rest of the offseason? I'd just as soon sign him(or Fielder) and call it an offseason, unless we can get Sizemore for cheap and perhaps a cheap reclamation type starting pitcher and call it a day. I'd then like to keep building next offseason when we have the Dempster, Zambrano, Byrd, and remaining Pena money off the books, and see what's available then through FA or trade. Our shopping list for the next 2 years is: 1st Base 3rd Base Corner OF Front line Starting Pitcher Mid Rotation Stating pitcher Perhaps a 2nd baseman, but first I'd like to cycle through guys like DeWitt, LeMahieu, Flaherty, and perhaps Junior Lake. Maybe a cheap RH backup outfielder. That will run us at least 70 Mil if we acquire all through free agency, which is doubtful judging by Theo's philospohy, but that's pretty much what's coming off the books between now and next October.