It's a mistake to play Floyd over Murton? Not so far it isn't. The '07 regular season numbers disagree with you. This isn't the prospect development league. The Cubs are out to win ballgames. The only position players slugging .400+ are DLee, ARam, DeRosa (now injured), and Floyd. Floyd is one of the better hitters on this team right now and isn't costing us in the field. But I guess you're right, we should play Murton irregardless of performance on the field. You're really saying that Murton's 16 AB's and Floyd's 25 AB's can justify continuing to bench Murton, even though he has been very good the past 2 seasons? When he's looking absolutely lost and un-Murton-like at the plate? Absolutely. He's not working the count like he usually does and he's hitting weak dribblers that don't make it out of the IF. Face it, he's playing like crap and until he starts getting it figured out, Floyd should be starting over him (as Floyd is one of the better hitters on this team right now).