There's not a single player out there this winter that's better than Ramirez. I'd take a combo of D-Lee/C-Lee/Soriano/Barrett most games of the year over D-Lee/Aramis/Barrett (on a catcher's schedule). Aramis is better in every way than either of those 2 players. Why not just sign one of them and keep Aramis? Regardless, you can't trade Aramis now anyway. The latter: I know, this is all hypothetical. The former: I think the 2 combined would be better, more productive and more consistent than Aramis. I also think they'd be able to hold up if another big hitter goes down for an extended period of time. Sadly, I don't think the Cubs can hope for any significant improvement unless they sign both players, or 2 players along their lines. Hendry has created a sucking black hole of offense between 2nd base and SS and the OF has so little power between the corner spots it's not even funny. I think RF could be salvaged next year with a Murton/Jones platoon, but LF needs to the big boost desperately. Murton is not the answer there at this point. I'd sign a big bat for LF longterm, let Murt platoon in RF with Jacque, and then he takes over RF fulltime when Jacque is gone. Hopefully his power has developed enough at that point. By then you'd have Big Bat TBNL in left, Pie in CF and Murton in RF. The problem with picking up 2 players along these lines is it doesn't leave much money to fix up the starting rotation. Hence why I'd be willing to have traded Aramis. Ok, let me go point by point here. Here are the last 3 years for Carlos Lee, Soriano, and Aramis Lee: (age 30 now) 04-.305/.366/.525 05-.265/.324/.487 06-.295/.350/.536 Soriano (age 30 now) 04-.280/.324/.484 05-.268/.309/.512 06-.294/.366/.602 Aramis (age 28 now) 04-.318/.373/.578 05-.302/.358/.568 06-.279/.341/.544 Aramis is 2 years younger then either of these two-his worst year is the same as Carlos Lee's 2 best years of the 3, and his worst year is also much better than 2 of the 3 years of Soriano. Why are these other 2 players going to stay more productive than Aramis? Second-yes, the offense in the middle infield is bad right now. However, the power specifically is not terrible at all in RF. Jones is 4th in HR, and 5th in SLG percentage among right fielders in the major leagues. I do agree that a Murton and Jones platoon would be excellent, but if you're already signing Soriano to provide power at 2nd, Murton would be fine in LF without the power (you have 2 positions now providing power that are not supposed to, C and 2b, and only 1 position that is not providing power that is traditionally supposed to, LF). Sign another platoon partner for Jacque, and you have 30-40 HR's out of RF, while increasing the OBP of RF also significantly (Jones's OBP against right handers makes him a dangerous weapon when combined with his SLG-.309/.350/542 against right handers this season-slightly better than Carlos Lee-just have to find a player who can kill left handers to combine him with) Then, you only have to pick up 1 full-time player and 1 platoon player, and that still leaves you with money to fix the starting rotation and having an extremely productive offense.