Iman Shumpert has been terrible compared to the way he was pre-injury. With the exception of 3pt shooting, every stat is down from pre-injury. Rose is taking longer, yes. But the point is for him to be able to come back and not have to be a shadow of the player he was pre-injury. Will that actually happen? There's no telling of course, but if him taking a little longer to get right...what's being hurt by that? Maybe the Bulls are out of the playoffs a round earlier than they would have otherwise? You're getting back to ridiculousness here. Comparing Rose's ACL to Nate Robinson's flu symptoms? Yep, that's the same. None of the guys you listed are dealing with an injury of the severity that Rose's was. And frankly, I'd rather that Deng had sat, maybe gotten surgery to get his wrist right. I'd rather that Noah had sat for longer and not tried to play through his plantar fascitis, so we could have gotten more of 100% Noah instead of some of the gimpy games we've gotten. Playing through injury isn't always the right move. I will agree with you that the PR aspect of all of this should've been handled better. Reggie, of course, should shut the [expletive] up. And both Rose and the Bulls should've allowed more for the possibility that he misses the season right from the start. But the vilification is way WAY over the top. Rose didn't kill anyone, or rape anyone, or wreck his sportscar on Lakeshore, or whatever other endless amount of stupidity that athletes are forgiven for. The only difference is that he hasn't been back on the court yet, to do all those great things that make people forgive athletes' mistakes. As soon he does, all this will be forgotten.