Well, if the catch yesterday happened as Bryant was heading out of bounds, he wouldn't have reached the ball forward for the end zone. My scenario could be in the middle of the field. So, if the player gets greedy with his ball control it's catch? I'm confused what your point is. Just looking for clarification. "Greedy with his ball control" implies that he had control of the ball already, which would have made him down by contact. I hate that im arguing this so much because it's really in that nebulous realm that I can see it going either way, and Dallas was not going to stop Rodgers from going back down the field so ultimately it probably doesn't matter. I just think if a receiver snatches the ball, gets three feet in and the ball falls out as he reaches for the end zone, it's a catch. I can see if he's bobbling the thing, but it seemed like he had total control, enough to forcibly reach his hands out.