Guess you can say he was a pleasant surprise :) I don't know about that. He still has had problems allowing rookies to adjust to the bigs... Pie had almost no chance at all, and Fukudome getting benched with the lead we have in the division was just plain stupid. And there's no doubting that he's made plenty of stupid in-game moves... and they seem to come more often in games he deems critical, which makes me nervous about seeing Soto trying to bunt again during the playoffs. He's been better than I expected, but he hasn't been fantastic. +1. He's been good, but let's remember that Dusty got us to within 5 outs of a WS and we all knew he sucked. I really wanted Girardi, but then again, I didn't expect them to sign Soriano, Lilly, Marquis, etc...and then follow that up with Fukudome, Harden trade, etc. I still think Soto should have been called up last year a few months earlier and Pie should have gotten more of a chance, but that is just as much JHs call as it is Lou's (see Kendall, Jason and Edmonds, Jim--who were both pretty good).