they're both bad, we picked up valbuena from the scrap heap. we gave up a decent 26 year old 4th of for stewart. I totally agree with this. If you delve into the backwoods of the internet too, you can find Rockies fan posts from a few years back lamenting that he refused to get his wrist surgery, and how obvious it was to them that it was majorly affecting his production. Also TT, why do you refer to him as a platoon player? I agree with the sentiment he's a fourth OF most likely, but in 2010 his ops against lhp was actually higher(821/813), and this year while it's 60 points lower, it's still at 845 (911rhp). And yes I realize it's not fair to ignore his 2011 season, but, I just did.