Link The Sun-Times address your question, but doesn't really answer it. In my opinion, if you are going to create this so-called "surplus", then you trade it for young positional talent, not over-the-hill stop gaps. At the same time, I don't really see that this surpless has even emerged. The Rule V draft prohibits you from stockpiling ML-ready arms (lest Andy forget the Sisco Fiasco). Its all double talk. I no longer have much use for MacPhail. Here's my problem with what MacPhail is saying: If that is the true organizational philosophy, to emphasize pitching in the draft and acquire positional talent via free agency, why has the biggest offseason acquistion in the past few years been Greg Maddux?