The walks are certainly a concern, but Dempster's high K rate makes up for a lot of that. I'm actually more concerned with his HR allowed rate going forward. Before he came to the Cubs, Dempster was allowing HR at the rate of about one every 8-9 innings. Since coming here and spending the bulk of his time in the bullpen, that's gone down to about one every 22-23 innings. There are two ways of looking at that. The optimistic way would be to say that the move to the pen has helped him keep his HR rate down and K rate up. (Whether it's because hitters see less of his stuff or he can put more effort into each of his pitches.) The less optimistic way would be to say it's a product of the relatively small number of innings he's thrown while a Cub, and that over time his numbers will slide back to their previous, less-than-stellar levels. If I were to guess at it, I'd say it's a combination of the two. Dempster probably won't regress all the way back, but I wouldn't count on him having three seasons as good as this one, either. I agree with you about his HR rate, but Dempster's K/BB ratio is below average (it isn't even 1/2 of BJ Ryan's or Wagner's). So, I don't agree with you that Dempster's K's make up for his walks. We're not going to see '05 Dempster for a full season next year (well, the odds are against it). Why don't/didn't we spend the money to get an elite (and proven) closer?