Exactly. Metrics canot tell you about his professionalism and hustle, and the fact that he played on two gimpy knees for most of his career, yet put up HOF-like nos. In addition, he had an absolute rocket arm that was highly accurate (think Vlad Guerrero). Not to mention his performance in 87' was unmatched during that decade; I mean no one came close to putting up nos. like that during the 80's. It was astounding, particularly since he did it for this team: http://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/CHC/1987.shtml Yeah, its my heart strings that are being tugged (I was eleven that summer and worshipped the very ground he walked on), but I vote "yes". Dawson's 87 MVP vote one of the worst selections in the history of baseball. I know I'm going to look like a homer but check out Dawson's 87: .287/.328/.568 Now Jack Clark's: .286/.459/.597 :-k Andre Dawson was one of the most over rated players of his generation.