Exactly. If I invest $10m over multiple years in a player I want Top 3 production from his position in the league, for the length of the contract. Damon won't deliver that. Give me a list of ten players who have in the last 10 years produced in the top 3 for his position every single year of the contract and had a top 5 salary for the position. Good luck. Alex Rodriguez, Barry Bonds, Albert Pujols and Manny Ramirez come immediatly to mind. Of course, those deals are still in progress, but you'd be hard pressed to see a signifigant decline from any of those guys. That's just 4 off the top of my head. Also, your response basically confirmed what I am trying to say: big money players rarely are worth their salaries for the length of the contract, so you have to be careful who you shell out 8 figures to. Damon is a nice player, but not worth his asking price, and certainly not at the cost of blocking Pie.