Which one is which? A: Free agent after 2012, 4.8 WAR last 3 years, Best 3 seasons - 4.2, 1.7, 1.6 B: Free agent after 2012, 7.8 WAR last 3 years, Best 3 seasons - 4.4, 3.9, 3.2 Going forward, Cabrera is a better bet to outproduce Byrd with the 7 year age advantage and all. Maybe he is that 800 OPS guy he was last year, but I wouldn't count on it especially when combined with the less than stellar defense. I'd give him a shot over Byrd next year, but I certainly wouldn't give up more than a fringe prospect or two to get him.