I don't think it's fair to blame this year's pitching woes on Barrett. I don't have the time or desire to look up stats to back this up, I just can't imagine that his presence alone has made our pitcher's this bad. The fact that we've had to use such a jumbled rotation, including Williams, Hill, Mitre, Rusch, and Koronka (others?) due to injuries and ineffectiveness, I think shows that this is more than just a question of who's doing the catching. Z's been pretty good actually, Maddux is about what you'd expect at this point, Prior hasn't been awful, and we can't blame Barrett for Wood's injuries (I don't think). The bullpen has been very shaky and again I don't think Barrett's presence has really effected them a great deal. I'm not saying you're blaming Barrett, but I don't agree with the argument I think you're making (Miller or another defensive catcher would have a significant effect on the Cubs pitching this year).