Stitch, there was a sportstalk show host in Cleveland by the name of Pete Franklin (God rest his soul). Pete used to scream at callers who thought that a team could win based on offense alone. He used to say that pitching was 90% of the game. I'm not going to go that far, but pitching and defense make up about 75-80% of the game. No question that you need to score runs, but it's not nearly as important as having solid pitching and solid defense, especially up the middle. In the 2006 Baseball America Prospect Handbook, (page 8) there is a really good overview of what scouts are looking for at each position. Under shortstop, hitting ranks third behind fielding and arm strength. In center, hitting ranks second behind fielding. The catcher position has hitting third behind fielding and arm strength. Surprisingly, second base has hitting in front of fielding. BTW, the five categories were Fielding, hitting, speed, power and arm strength.