Hard pressed? Among NL catchers with 150 or more plate appearances, 8 have a higher AVG, 13 have a higher OBP and 1 has a higher SLG. Michael Barrett is a talented athlete, and has pop in his bat. But like many Cubs, he's terribly unrefined and has a terrible approach at the plate. His sub .300 OBP is a huge drag on this offense. It's truely an awful number, and that alone makes it impossible to call him productive. A handful of homeruns doesn't change his season long inability to get on base. You're right, his OBP is bad. I would love to see him take more pitches and get more walks, but that is not the way he hits. He goes after pitches he likes early. If he took more pitches, he might work himself into bad hitters counts and be even less effective. OBP is important, but hitting from the 8 spot, its not the most important thing. It is unlikely he would be hit home by the pitcher/pinch hitter up after him, anyway. If he were up in the order, that would be a different story.