Your point: It's too early to give up on Minor, because Roy Halladay had similar struggles early in his career. Response: Well, judging from the other 61 examples of highly regarded players struggling early in their career, odds aren't good for Minor. But sure, misinterpreting, laughs, whatever makes you feel better about it. My point: You don't give up on a recent top prospect after 180 innings and you don't ignore trading a half season rental of a 35 year old pitcher who won't be on the team next year for him. Especially when that player will still be under team control for several years Roy Halladay was merely an example, not the reason. If you all sincerely think the latter, well then... okay. The last three pages of this thread were discussing 61 reasons you do kind of give up on a recent top prospect after 25 miserable starts. You pointing out Roy Halladay is just using the exception to try to prove your rule.