Meh, Reyes is overrated. Let the best pitcher win the 5th spot, if that is Ponson than so be it. If Reyes is outpitched by Ponson, some stars will have aligned in a form I have never seen before. At this stage, it's all spec. but I can't see Ponson even coming close to outpitching Reyes. I agree, Reyes should win. However, I refuse to be close minded about Ponson. CFICT, I hope to give you the respect your posting here deserves. But I refuse to buy into this Ponson hype that is accorded to everyone that dons a Cardinal uniform, after the initial dismay. Ponson never was an elite pitcher and although his numerous alcohol-related arrests points to a reason, I'm shying away from this feel good story. The fact that he's even considered as competition for a starting spot and spring training will be the "showdown" is insulting to me and it should be insulting to Anthony Reyes. Hopefully that will prove motivating to Reyes and not de-motivating. As Wolf has said before, you can't teach healthy. That being said I'm not going to boo him on the mound if he happens to win the job over Reyes. I'm just going to wait for the other shoe to drop and lament Reyes' dwindling chances to prove himself while still with the Cards. indifferent, I repect your post and I happen to agree with many of your points however the Cardinals are in a win now mode and should go with whatever is working. I expect Reyes to win the job however I'm not ready to hand over the #5 spot if he comes in to spring training and stinks it up. Right now a lot of Cardinal Nation overrates Reyes potential for 06. His ceiling in the next couple of years is a #2 starter however right now he’s a rookie backend guy fighting for a spot. That isn’t insulting to Reyes, it’s just a fact. Question – What kind of numbers do you expect from Reyes? I certainly expect his ERA to be over 4. If he posts a 4.00 ERA, I wouldn't be disappointed. What do you expect out of Ponson and Marquis? Unlike the other two though, Reyes has far more upside. I'd say they both have a better chance of finishing over 4.00. The biggest risk with Reyes is he could hit a dead arm period because of his lack of innings. He's been well handled in the minors. There's no reason not to have Reyes in rotation IMO, stellar ST or not-so-stellar ST.