As has been pointed out on NSBB, Pierre is not that great of a baserunner. He was caught stealing 20 times this year; he succeeded 58 times (74% success rate). This is consistent with his career average, as he has stolen 325 of 441 (74%). In order to "break even" - that is, to be be neither beneficial nor detrimental to your team as a baserunner - I believe a runner must average about 70%. (Hopefully another poster can provide the specific stat.) He is a pretty good runner, but not efficient or productive enough to warrant a hefty contract. When it comes to hits, of course he accumulates a lot of them batting leadoff and playing 162 games/year. However, he also gets out quite a bit. While his batting average is respectable, his on-base percentage is lacking. This year, he reached base at a .330 clip. His career average is .350 (a solid number), but he has been very inconsistent from year to year: 2000 .353 2001 .378 2002 .332 2003 .361 2004 .374 2005 .326 2006 .330 His most recent two years are alarming, and certainly not productive enough for a leadoff hitter. In comparison, Todd Walker had an OBP of .355 in 2005 with the Cubs, and .352 (Cubs) and .366 (Padres) this season. Walker's career OBP is .349, and he costs his team a fraction of the price Pierre does and will following his next contract. As Pierre ages, his ability to run out scrappy hits presumably will decrease. That he offers no advantages on defense (except for speed) also does not justify his pricetag. All this said, I like Pierre and his attitude. However, if the Cubs are looking at cost effective improvements in production, they should look elsewhere. EDIT: Mods, can the Pierre talk be merged into its own thread?