Thats a tough one. While Chipper is going to hit for great average, Byrnes and Giambi are going to drive you crazy. I had Giambi last year and his BA is the reason I came in third, not second. If you can stomach the two guys bringing down your average then maybe. You're selling low on Dye and Rolen though. If steals is a concern, try to get away from these massive trades and target just one guy who will make a big impact. Byrnes is gonna do OK on steals, but probably not enough to make a material difference. You could just replace Uggla with Theriot in your lineup. If I were you, I'd try to sell high on Bonds and Hamilton and pick yourself up a really good pitcher and an average/steals OF such as Taveras, Victorino, Lofton, or Pierre. You've got enough power in other places to have one of them in your lineup. We don't have average in our league, we have OPS instead. That should benefit Giambi some. I have already replaced Uggla with Theriot so I agree with you there. I agree that Byrnes is fairly mediocre and basically a toss in. It's a tough call for sure. Thanks for the input. Ahh, well yeah that changes things for Giambi. Hes a huge upgrade over Nomar, and Chipper is an upgrade over Rolen, but you have to worry about injury. I guess it really depends on how you feel about Dye, is he going to be like 2005 or 2006. PECOTA says 2005, so it actually wouldnt be that big of a downgrade to Alou/Byrnes. The trade isn't going to really help your SB issue, but it should make your team better.