I'm not sure whether you think Bobby Hill was a prospect or not. You seem to mention him in different lights in two places. But let's see: Where was the outcry when Dontrelle Willis was traded? I'm sure he'd like to have that one back, but at the time, Willis was in the low minors. Hinske had a great first year, but how will be do long term? If any big-market GM could have gotten Ramirez, why didn't they? The Cubs got an absolute steal there, so much so that Matt Bruback didn't last with the Pirates and Bobby Hill isn't playing every day. Tell me again who the Cubs gave up to get Randall Simon, who helped the Cubs immensely last year. The jury is still out on the drafts, and it's "John" Stockstill. Hawkins was a key signing and had offers elsewhere. The Cubs wanted to pre-empt another team from getting him. "Arm-grinder" Baker has a pretty good record of keeping his pitchers off the operating table. Can "geniuses" such as Tony La Russa and Dave Duncan say the same thing? Nope. Yes, there are clinkers: Alfonseca, Estes, Guthrie, Veres (and not keeping Beck last year), but every GM has those too.