Supposedly his shoulder will be healthy going into spring training. Hes played the last two years with it being useless, trying to play through the pain and having cortisone shots. if Soriano had injuries that he played through in 04-05, would you excuse his drop in OPS? it's something that hasn't been discussed much around here. now Soriano was by no means my first choice for the Cubs, but the fact is the biggest ammunition that his critics have is his 04-05 seasons when he switched to a different division, Showalter gave him hell, and he played through injuries. Switching to different divisions? Seriously? Well he switched leagues last year and that didn't seem to hurt him. Plus he switched from the tough AL East to the less tough AL West. I've never heard anyone use the switching divisions excuse, thats hilarious. I don't know if Showalter gave him hell, I think Showalter gives everyone hell, but thats probably about on par with Torre and Piniella. And for the "playing through injuries" I assume you are talking about when Soriano tore his hamstring mid-sept in 2004. Well he actually didn't play another game the rest of the season. So there goes your theory for 04. He had a clean bill of health going into 05. He did reaggrivate it in June and sat out a few games. If playing through injuries was the case, then from this point on you would have seen his numbers go down. He had an 873 OPS at this point. However, he actually game back an hit better initially, reaching a high of 931 a few weeks later, ending June at 870. He ended July at 856, ending August at 852. He really struggled the last two weeks in Sept. There were no reports about the hammy nagging him or anything. Your points would hold water if they were actually true. when you go from playing on the Yankees and hitting against the pitching of the D-Rays, Toronto, Boston, and Baltimore to the larger parks in the AL West, and the significantly better pitching he faced and the larger ballparks he played in, yes, the differences in the two divisions is pretty significant. for playing through injuries, I am particularly talking about the leg injury he suffered in late ST 2004 which ailed him for about two and a half months and was aggrevated in late April 2004. not coincidentally, May 2004 dragged his season stats down significantly. regarding 2005, see your point about 2004's late season injury and look what month dragged his season stats down in in 2005 while his hammy was still a little ginger. Showalter also screwed with him from the second he arrived. this is about the best compilation of news and notes I've seen on Soriano. http://www.thomasgeorge.com/baseball/profile.cfm?playerId=1765&allNews=1 he was an immature kid, and probably remains so, but that was exacerbated by Showalter being a jerk to him all along. so. since my points hold water since they are actually true, I guess you are ready to back off of your criticism of Soriano and give his injuries and circumstances similar treatment as you do Wilkerson's, right?