I'm fairly confident that will be asked Every day, pal, every day. Next question. Look, I would have PH for Hoff too, but at the same time Hoff strikes out more (i think) and I still don't trust him at all against breaking pitches, as he's had trouble handling them in his big league ABs right but i think the only choices that make sense are hoff and gathright. if you're looking for a fly ball or a big inning, go with hoff. if you're afraid he'll K or is slow and will GIDP, put in gathright, who runs really well and doesn't K much. combine that with miles' poor track record against that pitcher and he was a poor option.